Friday, January 10, 2014

An Essay I wrote: Medical Controversy: Conventional versus Alternative Medicine


Medical Controversy: Conventional versus Alternative Medicine

The conventional medical system is set up in a way that people seldom realize that there are alternative choices available to them to remedy and ailment other than the typical prescription approach.  To illustrate, Debbie’s doctor hands a prescription to her for an oral steroid to clear up an allergic reaction she has to poison ivy; and all the while little does she know that there is an effective homeopathic remedy available to her.  The intent is not to have alternative medicine supersede conventional methods, as they are both valuable.  In fact, conventional medicine is an obvious necessity with its technological advances and procedures for acute illnesses.  And although more people are trying it, the use of alternative medicine in lieu of conventional medicine is still highly controversial.  Nevertheless, alternative medicine is a viable alternative to conventional medicine because it is evidence-based, provides a holistic approach to healing, and can be healthier than using prescription medications.

            In determining the advantages of alternative medicine versus conventional, the evidence must be scientifically based as opposed to group or individual opinion.  Homeopathic medicine is a science that has definitely withstood the test of time.  Specifically, over two hundred years ago homeopathy founder Dr. Samuel Hahnemann treated an Asiatic cholera epidemic which proved to be an astounding success according to conventional and homeopathic physicians alike (Coward, 2002).  If homeopathy were not proven to be an effective form of treatment, products like Hyland’s Complete Flu Care or Boiron’s Oscillococcinum would not be found on the shelves of stores today.  For instance, The Hyland’s Complete Flu Care made the news when the flu vaccine shortage occurred a few years ago because it significantly relieved flu symptoms (Stay Healthy, 2004).  Another popular alternative treatment is Chinese medicine, and although it has also been around for centuries there is still a lot of criticism on its efficacy.  In the past Chinese herbalists did not have the technology to assess the amount of cholesterol in a person’s bloodstream; however an herb known as red yeast rice has been proven to lower lipid levels.  “For example, LDL (low-density lipoprotein), HDL (high-density lipoprotein), triglycerides and total cholesterol are lowered when this herb is taken daily” (Deas, 2009, p. 30). 

            Another topic that is often related to alternative medicine is the way in which healing is viewed in treating the whole body.  In contrast, with conventional medicine, people are generally looking for an immediate cure, rather than actually healing.  So it is important to point out that alternative medicine places great emphasis on diagnosing and treating physically, emotionally, psychologically, and socially.  According to one practitioner, “conventional medicine tries to fix a problem rather than get to the heart of the issue”, and that goes to show that holism could be used to increase the quality of care to conventional medicine (Barrett et al., 2000, p. 236).  Furthermore, Dr. David Edelberg (2005), a conventional doctor who integrated uses an approach with his patients that he picked up from Dr. Carolyn Myss’s work, How Your Biography Affects Your Biology.  It is a method that gives a more detailed look into a person’s health status.  Dr. Edelberg is able to develop a complete treatment plan that he refers to as a “healing path” that focuses on complete health, for instance, suggestive readings, supplements, nutritional counseling, and alternative therapies.

            Although prescription medications can be effective, there are significant health risks that people need to be better educated about.  If more information was disclosed to the public about some of the modern medicine shortcomings there might be more interest in learning more about alternative methods.  It is truly amazing what is kept from the headlines in order to protect the pharmaceutical industry.  For instance, “hormone replacement treatment was found to be unsafe; cyclo-oxygenase (COX) inhibitors were found to be unsafe and to have caused potentially more than 100 deaths” and a firm tried to cover it up (Walach, 2009, p. 1141).  Patients take prescription drugs because they, more times than none, assume the doctor knows best.  If they were to question the treatment methods more they would soon find out that there are other ways.  As mentioned earlier, red yeast rice has been proven to lower total cholesterol; and yet Lipitor, “which has not been shown to prevent heart disease or heart attacks” is one of the most common Statin drugs to be dispensed.  Over 18 million people use it without any evidence that will improve the length or quality of their lives (Coward, 2002).  Statin drugs have side effects like muscle spasms, as well as a loss of co-enzyme Q10 “a very important nutrient necessary for the heart muscle to be efficient” (Deas, 2009).  In much the same way, according to several studies, antidepressants such as Prozac, Paxil, and Effexor may help ease hot flashes for menopausal women, but potential side effects include fatigue, sexual dysfunction, and weight gain (Which Alternative Treatments Work?, 2005, p. 43).

            To summarize, alternative medicine is a viable alternative to conventional medicine because it is evidence-based, provides a holistic approach to healing, and can be healthier than using prescription medications.  And even though conventional medicine is necessary to have because of the technology, it can “easily do harm” (Barrett et al., p. 237).  It is important to have knowledge about both methods in order to make the best decision possible when it pertains to one’s overall health.  Everyone should be educated about all the alternative options that are evidence-based, holistic, and healthy.

           

References

Barrett, B., Marchand, L., Scheder, J., Applebaum, D., Chapman, M., Jacobs, C., et al. (2000). Bridging the Gap between Conventional and Alternative Medicine. Journal of Family Practice, 49 (3), 234-239.  Retrieved from Academic Search Premier Database.

Coward, S. (2002).  Conventional Medicine, Homeopathy, & Science. New Life Journal: Carolina Edition, 4 (2), 3.  Retrieved from Health Source – Consumer Edition Database.

Deas, G. (2009). Red yeast rice is nice—to your blood vessels. New York Amsterdam News, 100 (35), 30.  Retrieved from Academic Search Premier Database.

Edelberg, David. (2005). One Internist’s Transition to Alternative Medicine.  Total Health, 27 (5), 48-49.  Retrieved from Health Source Consumer Edition Database.

(2004). Stay Healthy during the Flu Vaccine Shortage. Total Health, 26(5), 52.  Retrieved from Health Source – Consumer Edition Database.

Walach, H. (2009). The Campaign against CAM and the Notion of “Evidence-Based”.  Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine, 15 (10), 1139-1142.  doi:10.1089/acm.2009.0423.

(2005). Which Alternative Treatments Work? Consumer Reports, 70 (8), p39-43, 5p, 1 cartoon.  Retrieved from Academic Search Elite.

 

 

Thursday, January 9, 2014

Take control of your health :)

For those who may be interested here is a link to a trustworthy e-health source:


http://www.healthit.gov/patients-families/ehealth



Wellness tools and resources
Managing health conditions
Managing medical bills
Maintaining medical records
Supporting family caregivers





Diabetes Awareness Month

  Helpful Information Related to Diabetes   Diabetes mellitus (DM) affects how the body uses blood sugar aka glucose. In fact, the pancreas...