Nutrition-Based
Web Site Review
Today, there is an abundance of
health information available to health professionals and the general public via
the World Wide Web. With the rising
costs of healthcare, and the staggering numbers of individuals who are either
underinsured or uninsured, self-help is becoming more prevalent. Specifically, people are becoming more
informed about their health by accessing various web sites. With that noted, the question that arises is,
how useful are these web sites? In the
midst of the continual rise in chronic condition and disease statistics, health
and nutrition education is essential. Obesity
is on the forefront of such statistics. And,
studies have shown that individuals who do not participate in regular physical
activity and who lack a nutritious diet are more likely to become obese.
According to the Centers for Disease
Control and Prevention (CDC), “Children and adolescents should participate in one
hour of physical activity (moderate/vigorous) each day” (How Much Physical
Activity Do Children Need, 2011). Furthermore,
adults should participate in at least “Two hours and thirty minutes” of
physical activity (moderate) each week, which would be thirty minutes a day,
five days out of the week (How Much Physical Activity Do Adults Need, 2011). Unfortunately, those recommendations are most
likely seldom met by numerous individuals because it is commonly known that too
many children spend an excessive amount of time watching television or
gaming. And, many adults might be sedentary,
consumed by their work, or busy caring for others to take time for themselves
and their health and nutrition. As a
result, physical inactivity combined with poor diet contributes to “17% of children
ages 2-19” who are obese in the United States, as well as the nearly 36% of
obese adults (Overweight and Obesity: Adult and Child Obesity Facts,
2012-2013). For this reason, a review of
publications that focus on web-based interventions for physical activity and
nutrition in both adolescents and adults will be discussed.
Scientific research can provide some
insight on how effective nutrition-based web sites are in providing help to
people; however, the following questions should be ultimately considered: Who determines the usefulness of
nutrition-based websites? The
individual (user) would be the likely candidate for that decision. Everyone is entitled to their own
opinion. What determines the usefulness of the web site? The individual’s personal preference would be
a factor in that decision. A program
that works for one individual may not work for another. And, how
is the effectiveness determined? Some might consider one’s age (life
experience) would contribute to that decision.
A child is more than likely going to have a different perception than an
adult.
In 2012, a study was conducted to
collect information from teenagers on how to design a web site in order to
promote “healthy eating and physical activity behaviors” (Thompson,
Weber-Cullen, Boushey, & Konzelmann, 2012, p.2). Incorporating cartoon characters, an easy to
use calculator for physical activity and healthy eating, stories, easy-to-make
recipes, and a diary were ideas discussed in the teenage focus groups. Animations, assessment tools, fun recipes,
are just a few things that grabbed their attention. Can any of these components be found in
kid-friendly nutrition-based web sites?
Yes. According to the
Agricultural Research Service (USDA), kidshealth.org and mypyramid.gov
provide some of the best online kid-focused health and nutrition information
(Helping Kids Fight Obesity, 2010). Individuals
can find interactive tools, stories, journals, recipes, and other helpful
resources on those web sites. The users in the study were teens and it was
they who determined what components would be considered useful to them on a web
site. This would probably vary with a
different target audience (younger children or adults).
A separate study was conducted on
“Internet-delivered interventions to increase physical activity levels”. The target audience (participant) average age
was 43 years. The databases utilized for
the study were “Pubmed, Proquest, Scopus, PsychINFO, CINHAL, and Sport Discuss”. There were 34 articles that represented the
interventions to increase physical activity (Davies, Spence, Vandelanotte,
Caperchione, & Mummery, 2012, p1-3).
Interestingly, the study was able to capture those factors such as
personalized content, goal setting, and self-monitoring that increased program
(intervention) effectiveness. Researchers
were able to conclude that internet-delivered interventions are effective in
producing an increase in physical activity for a small sample size. How can this positive behavior change occur in
larger proportions? There are several
web sites with that type of design accessible to adults. Fitday.com offers access to a
registered dietician, goal setting, and food and activity tracking (FitDay,
2013). Fitness.com and Choosemyplate.gov
are also great web sites to utilize depending on individual preference.
A concern that some may have is that there are
so many resources which can lead to a bit of confusion. For instance, The Centers for Disease Control
and Prevention has a web page for kids BAM which stands for Body and Mind (BAM,
n.d.). Nemours (Alfred I. DuPont
Hospital non-profit organization) created the KidsHealth.org web page (Kids
Health, 2013). And, the USDA created the
Choosemyplate.gov web page. These sites present
a variety of helpful information for kids by means they can easily relate to,
but how does one choose the right one for them?
It may just depend on what type of help they are seeking. Same question can be directed to adults as
well.
Nutrition-based web sites can be useful
for quick answers to weight/health related inquiries, or long-term diet and
physical activity analysis to help lose weight or maintain a healthful weight depending
on the user. Individuals regardless of age, who may be
suffering from obesity can get reliable (customized) information online and
have positive results.
Reference
Davies,
C., Spence, J., Vandelanotte, C., Caperchione, C., & Mummery, W. (2012,
April 30). Meta-analysis of
internet-delivered interventions to increase physical activity levels. Retrieved
February 3, 2013, from US National Library of Medicine National Institutes of
Health, International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity: http://www.ncbi.nlm.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3464872/
Thompson,
D., Weber-Cullen, K., Boushey, C., & Konzelmann, K. (2012). Design of a web site on nutrition and
physical activity for adolescents: Results from formative research. Retrieved
February 4, 2013, from Journal of Medical Internet Research: http://www.jmir.org/2012/2/e59/