Thursday, May 22, 2014

Environmental & Ethical Issues of Food Animal Production


Environmental & Ethical Issues of Food Animal Production

            The average consumer most generally does not know all that is entailed in food production, let alone whole food animal production. And, sometimes the consumer only sees or hears one side whether it be conventional production practices or organic production practices. The article Environmental Aspects of Ethical Animal Production sheds light on issues with both. In attempting to figure out a happy medium, producers have to take into account how their operations affect “animal welfare” and the environment. Siegford, Powers, and Grimes-Casey provide excellent research with regard to issues of production practices “impact of animal behavior”, “nutrient loading and leaching”, “pathogenic releases”, “emissions into air”, and “resource intensity” (2008, p. 381-384).     

            While pasture-based farm productions promote the natural behavior of animals there is concern regarding the negative environmental impact of these farms if they are not designed and operated properly. For example, a pig’s (swine) natural behaviors are rooting and wallowing. Rooting is considered their “exploratory” behavior, and if they are not permitted to do such behavior they can become frustrated which negatively impacts their “animal welfare”. And, wallowing in the mud puddles is also natural; therefore, their environment must include areas for them to do this. Unfortunately, both can damage the pastures and increase leaching and emissions (p. 381). So, is the answer keeping them enclosed in large swine houses? Some would say yes, while others would disagree.

            Nutrient loading and leaching can be an issue if grazing is not rotated in pasture-based animal productions. In both settings, surface water and ground water can be contaminated if livestock are accessing streams without restrictions or leaching occurs from manure pits (p. 382). Then there are greenhouse gas emissions in both pasture and confined building productions. It could be argued that the confined buildings produce a stronger air pollutant as opposed to the pasture. For instance, nearby conventional confined swine and chicken farms can be quite potent year round and really bad during the warmer months. The authors pointed out that an increase in the oilseed-based feed could help decrease the methane production in the pasture-based livestock (Siegford, Powers, & Grimes-Casey, 2008, p. 382). The organic pasture productions “promote greater biodiversity in soils as well as greater in soils as well as greater soil fertility, reducing the need for fertilizer and pesticide inputs” (p. 384). However, these productions require more land for the livestock. Can we have the best of both, or one or the other? Is it worth it for the consumer to spend a little more money on foods that come from humane environments, producers who take into account their impact on the environment, or from conventional producers? There are many questions one could ask.

            In my opinion, the benefits of pasture-based production outweigh the environmental concerns. I believe that both the environmental health and human health impacts of the large conventional confined productions are of much more concern than those of organic-based productions. Even after reading the article, I still feel as though the organic productions are much more sustainable and the animals are in a better living environment. It is worth educating the consumers about both types of operations so that they have a better understanding of what all is involved in food animal production.

 

 Reference

Seigford, J.M., Powers, W., & Grimes-Casey, H.G. (2008, Feb). Environmental aspects of ethical animal production. Poult. Sci., 87 (2), 380-6.



Diabetes Awareness Month

  Helpful Information Related to Diabetes   Diabetes mellitus (DM) affects how the body uses blood sugar aka glucose. In fact, the pancreas...